Scissor Lifts vs. Cherry Pickers
Table of Contents
If you’ve ever needed to reach high places safely or get a bird’s-eye view of a project, consider using an aerial work platform. These nifty machines are a game-changer for various industries, from construction to maintenance.
Two of the most commonly used machines are scissor lifts and cherry pickers. But how do these two differ? How would you know which one should you use?
Let’s help you find out!
What are Scissor Lifts
When it comes to aerial work platforms, scissor lifts are like workhorses. Their name comes from the crisscrossing metal supports that make up their lifting mechanism and resemble a scissor when stretched. With a solely vertical raising motion, these platforms feature a straightforward yet sturdy construction.
Scissor lifts are similar to Swiss Army tools in aerial work platforms. They are the most common choice for a variety of jobs and industries. Think about maintenance work: scissor lifts are right there with you, whether painting inside or replacing lights on a ceiling. However, they are not just found indoors; you can also see them working on numerous jobs at building sites outside.
Advantages of scissor lifts:
- Safety and stability features: You can rely on stability with scissor lifts. They don’t wobble much, even when you’re up high, because of their solid construction.
- Size and capacity of the platform: Scissor lifts are beautiful since they come in various sizes. Therefore, you have alternatives, whether you need a little platform for a small workplace or something larger to handle big equipment.
- Use both inside and outside: Scissor lifts are up to the task, whether you’re working indoors with fluorescent lights or outside in the weather. Their adaptability makes them a wise choice in a variety of settings.
Limitations of scissor lifts:
- Limited vertical reach: Scissor lifts could be better at sideways or diagonal movements, like elevators that only travel up and down. Therefore, there might be better choices if your profession requires you to reach significant heights.
- Restricted outreach: Imagine having to reach over a barrier in your way. Because their arms can’t extend as far as cherry pickers can, scissor lifts may struggle in this situation.
- Maneuverability challenges: Scissor lifts may be similar to piloting a large ship through a narrow canal in small places. Therefore, if your workplace is cramped or obstructed, you could find it difficult to move about.
What is a Cherry Picker
Now, let’s shift our gaze to the Cherry Pickers, also known as Aerial Boom Lifts. Imagine a giant arm that extends high into the sky, with a platform at the end – that’s what a cherry picker looks like. These lifts are the kings of reaching extreme heights and tricky angles.
When you must reach high places, cherry pickers act as the aerial work platform equivalent of superheroes, swooping in to save the day. They are frequently used in the building and tree-trimming sectors and filmmaking for the dramatic overhead views.
Advantages of cherry pickers:
- Greater height and outreach capabilities: Cherry pickers are your greatest buddies if you have a profession that requires a lot of height. Compared to most other aerial platforms, they can stretch higher and further.
- Articulating and telescopic options: There are two types of cherry pickers: articulating and telescopic. The articulating ones are the group’s acrobats, bending and twisting to fit through the narrow spaces. The clear winners for such high jobs are telescopic cherry pickers.
- Enhanced maneuverability: Cherry pickers may be very agile, given their lengthy arms. They are very useful in challenging workplaces because of their ability to rotate, pivot, and move in all directions.
Limitations of cherry pickers:
- Stability concerns at heights: You could notice the sway more as you ascend. Extreme heights can make cherry pickers a little unsteady, which is nerve-racking for operators.
- Limited ground clearance: Off-road vehicles aren’t precisely cherry pickers. They may struggle to traverse tough terrain because of their low ground clearance.
- Limitations on outdoor use during bad weather: Cherry picker operations can be hampered by snow, wind, and rain. Outdoor activities may be difficult when Mother Nature isn’t cooperative since they don’t get along well with terrible weather.
Scissor Lifts vs Cherry Pickers – Which One Do You Actually Need?
When reaching for the sky or navigating challenging workspaces, having the right aerial work platform can make all the difference. Scissor lifts and cherry pickers (also known as aerial boom lifts) are two popular options that cater to different needs. Which one do you actually need?
Scissor Lifts for Stability and Versatility:
Scissor lifts are advantageous for those who require a stable platform when working at height. They provide minimal wobbling, making them suitable for delicate tasks or heavy machinery. Scissor lifts are flexible and can be used indoors for various purposes, such as maintenance, painting, and decorating. They are adaptable in confined spaces and can carry tools and materials. Furthermore, scissor lifts are budget-friendly compared to cherry pickers, offering a cost-effective solution without compromising safety or performance.
Cherry Pickers for Reaching New Heights and Navigating Tight Spaces:
Cherry pickers are aerial boom lifts essential in tasks requiring elevated perspectives, such as construction and tree trimming. They offer maneuverability that scissors lifts can’t match, with articulating cherry pickers able to access tight spaces and telescopic ones providing straight-line reach. Cherry pickers are also reliable performers in outdoor environments, handling varied terrains and weather conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Even though cherry pickers are intended for outdoor usage, inclement weather, such as persistent rain, high winds, or snow, might make it more difficult for them to operate safely. In inclement weather, operators should use caution and adhere to safety procedures.
Comparatively speaking, scissor lifts are simpler to move than cherry pickers. They are more handy for mobility because they frequently fit on a trailer and may be hauled to various job sites.
Yes, both equipment need routine upkeep to function safely and effectively. Regular checks, service, and adherence to manufacturer-recommended maintenance regimens are essential for their lifespan and safety.
Yes, some regulations and standards govern these aerial work platforms, including the United States’ OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration) guidelines. It’s important to adhere to these regulations to ensure operator safety and prevent accidents.
Conclusion
Assessing your particular needs and priorities is the key to choosing between scissor lifts and cherry pickers. Are you after stability and versatility for indoor tasks, or do you need to reach new heights and navigate tight spaces in the great outdoors? Aerial work platforms are prepared to meet the needs of your project, no matter what they may be.
It would be best to remember that choosing between a scissor lift and a cherry picker isn’t only about the equipment; it’s also about increasing your production and efficiency and, most importantly, ensuring everyone gets home safely at the end of the day.
Because of this, you’ll know exactly which aerial work platform to use the next time you address those difficult-to-reach areas. Stay safe and efficient, and keep reaching new heights in your projects!